Download After Gödel: Platonism and Rationalism in Mathematics and by Richard Tieszen PDF

By Richard Tieszen

ISBN-10: 019960620X

ISBN-13: 9780199606207

Richard Tieszen offers an research, improvement, and safeguard of a couple of valuable principles in Kurt Godel's writings at the philosophy and foundations of arithmetic and good judgment. Tieszen buildings the argument round Godel's 3 philosophical heroes - Plato, Leibniz, and Husserl - and his engagement with Kant, and vitamins shut readings of Godel's texts on foundations with fabrics from Godel's Nachlass and from Hao Wang's discussions with Godel. in addition to supplying discussions of Godel's perspectives at the philosophical importance of his technical effects on completeness, incompleteness, undecidability, consistency proofs, speed-up theorems, and independence proofs, Tieszen furnishes an in depth research of Godel's critique of Hilbert and Carnap, and of his next flip to Husserl's transcendental philosophy in 1959. in this foundation, a brand new kind of platonic rationalism that calls for rational instinct, known as 'constituted platonism', is built and defended. Tieszen indicates how constituted platonism addresses the matter of the objectivity of arithmetic and of the information of summary mathematical items. ultimately, he considers the results of this place for the declare that human minds ('monads') are machines, and discusses the problems of pragmatic holism and rationalism.

Show description

Read Online or Download After Gödel: Platonism and Rationalism in Mathematics and Logic PDF

Best mathematics books

Mathematical Methods for Physicists (6th Edition)

This best-selling name offers in a single convenient quantity the basic mathematical instruments and methods used to unravel difficulties in physics. it's a important addition to the bookshelf of any critical pupil of physics or study specialist within the box. The authors have positioned massive attempt into revamping this new version.

Duality for Nonconvex Approximation and Optimization

During this monograph the writer provides the idea of duality for nonconvex approximation in normed linear areas and nonconvex worldwide optimization in in the community convex areas. specified proofs of effects are given, in addition to diverse illustrations. whereas a few of the effects were released in mathematical journals, this can be the 1st time those effects look in booklet shape.

Automatic Sequences (De Gruyter Expositions in Mathematics, 36)

Computerized sequences are sequences that are produced by way of a finite automaton. even supposing they aren't random, they could glance as being random. they're advanced, within the feel of now not being finally periodic. they might additionally glance quite advanced, within the experience that it can now not be effortless to call the rule of thumb in which the series is generated; in spite of the fact that, there exists a rule which generates the series.

AMERICAN WRITERS, Retrospective Supplement I

This number of severe and biographical articles covers outstanding authors from the seventeenth century to the current day.

Additional info for After Gödel: Platonism and Rationalism in Mathematics and Logic

Sample text

If we consider formulas that can be proved in both systems, however, then the result says that if the length of a proof is defined to be the number of lines in the proof, then the proof of a given formula in Si + 1 will be much shorter than the shortest proof in Si. To be more precise, it says that for each function ç that is computable in Si there exist infinitely many formulas f such that if k is the length of the shortest proof of f in Si and l is the length of the shortest proof of f in Si + 1, then k > f( l ).

Husserl, as we saw, refers to the transcendental ego in its full concreteness as a monad. Kant, like Leibniz and Plato, does not put the intentionality of human consciousness at the center of his philosophy. Kant is also not a platonist about mathematical objects or facts, and he mounts a critique of classical rationalism (including Leibniz). For Kant, knowledge is restricted to sensory intuition and the two forms of sensory intuition, space and time. Kant, unlike Husserl, distinguishes phenomena from noumena (which is what Wang calls Kant’s dualism in the first passage quoted above), and is able to develop the transcendental method far enough to show how empirical realism is compatible with transcendental idealism (see chapter 4), but in his work there is no question of showing how a kind of platonism or mathematical objectivism is compatible with transcendental idealism.

Speed-up results of this type are philosophically interesting because they indicate the benefits of ascending to more powerful formal systems. In terms of the interpretations of the formal systems involved and the related capacities of human reason, they indicate the benefits of ascending to higher-level conceptions in our thinking, and they suggest that it is not a good idea to insist that only the reasoning expressed in first-order logic is legitimate. George Boolos (Boolos 1987) gives an example of the premises and conclusion of an argument written in the language of first-order predicate logic with identity and function symbols that is logically valid and short, in the sense that the premises and conclusion contain only about 60 symbols.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.80 of 5 – based on 40 votes